Fee Download Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum
As one of guide collections to suggest, this Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum has some strong factors for you to review. This publication is very ideal with what you require now. Besides, you will additionally enjoy this publication Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum to check out considering that this is one of your referred publications to review. When getting something new based on experience, home entertainment, and various other lesson, you can use this book Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum as the bridge. Beginning to have reading routine can be gone through from numerous methods as well as from alternative sorts of books
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum
Fee Download Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum
Just for you today! Discover your preferred e-book right here by downloading and install and obtaining the soft documents of guide Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum This is not your time to traditionally visit guide stores to purchase a publication. Here, varieties of publication Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum and also collections are available to download. One of them is this Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum as your favored e-book. Obtaining this book Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum by online in this website could be recognized now by going to the link web page to download. It will certainly be simple. Why should be below?
Postures now this Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum as one of your book collection! But, it is not in your cabinet compilations. Why? This is guide Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum that is offered in soft file. You could download the soft documents of this incredible book Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum currently and in the link supplied. Yeah, various with the other individuals that search for book Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum outside, you could get simpler to position this book. When some individuals still stroll right into the store and search guide Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum, you are here just stay on your seat as well as get guide Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum.
While the other individuals in the store, they are uncertain to find this Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum directly. It could require even more times to go store by establishment. This is why we mean you this website. We will offer the best method as well as recommendation to obtain guide Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum Also this is soft data book, it will be ease to lug Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum wherever or save in your home. The distinction is that you might not require move the book Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum area to place. You might require just copy to the various other gadgets.
Currently, reading this spectacular Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum will certainly be simpler unless you get download the soft file right here. Just below! By clicking the connect to download Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum, you could start to obtain the book for your personal. Be the very first owner of this soft documents book Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum Make difference for the others and also obtain the very first to step forward for Liberty Of Conscience: In Defense Of America's Tradition Of Religious Equality, By Martha Nussbaum Present moment!
The respect for religious difference has formed the bedrock of our nation and made equality possible. Yet today we are told that “moral values”—code for a government shaped by religious concerns—must be the keystone of our social compact.
A rich and compelling chronicle of an essential idea, Liberty of Conscience tells the story of America’s great tradition of religious freedom. Philosopher Martha Nussbaum’s ambitious book is both a work of history and a pointed rejoinder to conservative efforts to break down barriers between church and state.
- Sales Rank: #960525 in Books
- Published on: 2010-01-05
- Released on: 2010-01-05
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.25" h x .94" w x 6.00" l, 1.18 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 416 pages
From Publishers Weekly
Starred Review. In this engrossing history of the religion clauses of the First Amendment, Nussbaum (Cultivating Humanity) makes a strong, thoroughgoing case for America as a haven of religious liberty for believers of all stripes. Beginning with an illuminating rehabilitation of Rhode Island founder Roger Williams as America's earliest defender of religious equality, Nussbaum continues by examining how Williams's ideals have been both upheld and abandoned throughout the nation's history. After detailing the adoption of the establishment and free exercise clauses, Nussbaum comments at length on how these fairly general, vague clauses have been fleshed out by more than two centuries of case law. Refreshingly, Nussbaum does not add to the acrimonious cacophony around the idea of separation of church and state. Rather than pushing for strict separation, she argues for what philosopher John Rawls calls overlapping consensus, which echoes Williams's belief that citizens who differ greatly on matters of ultimate meaning can still agree to respect each other's liberty of conscience. Nussbaum writes engagingly and with generosity; her critiques, particularly those of opinions written by Justices Scalia and Thomas, are pointed but respectful, and she demonstrates warm regard for Supreme Court plaintiffs who have braved persecution as they have followed the dictates of conscience. (Feb.)
Copyright � Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Despite codification in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, the U.S. has long struggled with the concept of freedom of religion. Nussbaum, ethical philosopher at the University of Chicago, plumbs the historical, political, philosophical, and legal debates surrounding religious freedom. She recalls troubling times in U.S. history when, fueled by xenophobia, Americans—even the Supreme Court—acquiesced in some curtailment of the religious freedom of others,�including suspicions and attacks against Catholics, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Mormons, Seventh Day Adventists, and atheists. She explores issues surrounding the word God in the Pledge of Allegiance, gay marriage, prayer in school, the influence of Christian fundamentalism, and fear of Islamic fundamentalism. Nussbaum documents the ways, large and small, that the Bush administration has actually subverted religious freedom, from faith-based initiatives that flirt with favoritism to actual proselytizing by prominent officials. At a time of unprecedented religious diversity and tension within the U.S., this is a thoughtful and penetrating look at religious freedom. --Vanessa Bush
About the Author
Martha Nussbaum, one of the leading moral philosophers of our time, holds appointments in the Law School, Divinity School, and Philosophy Department at the University of Chicago and is a board member in the university’s Human Rights Program. She is the author of twelve previous books on philosophy and ethics. Her book Cultivating Humanity won the Grawemeyer Award for Education. The recipient of twenty-two honorary degrees from universities around the world, she lives in Chicago, Illinois.
Most helpful customer reviews
46 of 61 people found the following review helpful.
A Problematic Perspective
By JMB1014
Martha Nussbaum is in danger of becoming the next Isaac Asimov - a freelance expert on everything in general. This book is more of a tour de force than a serious study. Nussbaum makes a good argument for "overlapping consensus" in discussing equality between the religion clauses in the First Amendment but really misses the boat when it comes to injurious religious practices - the major obstacle to the equality principle. (It was John Rawls who earlier argued for "overlapping consensus" between believers and non-believers.) She does this by merely shrugging off pernicious effects that religious practices can have. Why did the Pope recently have to meet with victims of abuse by Catholic clergy? Nussbaum also unaccountably gives a free pass to polygamy, which has been in the news lately. She is cavalier in dismissing Jon Krakauer's seriously troubling indictment of polygamy. He is a mountaineer, she asserts, and has no major credentials in religion. And who, precisely, is Ms. Nussbaum to complain about someone else's being a non-specialist? Yet Krakauer only shows part of the immense and disturbing problem that polygamy poses. Andrea Moore-Emmett, an award-winning journalist from Utah, exposed much deep ugliness and cruelty underlying polygamy in her study, "God's Brothel," which featured the harrowing accounts of 18 actual women who all lived under polygamy.
The problem is there are people who are willing to prey (no pun intended) on the credulous and inflict severe emotional and physical damage while claiming merely to be freely exercising their religion. This is where the equality principle - and Nussbaum's thesis - founder. After all, the Supreme Court has held that religious belief cannot be regulated but religiously-motivated conduct can. This is fortunate. But what is really left of free exercise at that rate? There is far too much misery and torment inflicted in the real world - today, here, now - for Nussbaum to hide behind the sort of dismissiveness that taints this study. Alas, one need not be a "smug atheist" to worry about the sins being committed as people anoint themselves prophets and act on their beliefs to the detriment of others. We act as though the abuses like those of the Inquisition could not happen here or be visited on anyone nowadays. Wrong. Emphatically wrong. It would be nice to think the Establishment Clause should move over and make equal time for the Free Exercise Clause but the fact is, when people insist they have God's sanction to do truly depraved things, in the name of exercising their religion, notional commentary trivializes the harsh realities and, ultimately, the power some religions hold, for good or ill, over the minds of their adherents.
I heard Dr. Nussbaum speaking on Bill Moyers on April 18 and I was struck by how she simply avoided difficult questions - and Moyers was gentle with her. She simply sidestepped the issue of what you do about religious people who refuse to recognize that others are entitled to equality. If people were as reasonable as her argument requires, we would not have the arrogant side of the debate over establishments of religion, where the religious right asserts "we believers are in the majority so we can dictate to others." We would not have the ugly side of religious expression where self-anointed prophets prey on the credulous and the young, and demand power and obedience from women and children under threat of eternal damnation. Nussbaum is a bright woman but she seems to be ensconced in the proverbial ivory tower. Reality is a lot less pleasant - and less accommodating to principles of equality - than she seems to grasp.
17 of 25 people found the following review helpful.
Surface-Level Scholarship
By Kevin Currie-Knight
For years, I have been fascinated by the legal and political questions involved in religion/state affairs. What do the religion clasuses of the first amendment permit and rule out? How can the state be neutral towards religion while repectful of it? I have read many books on these questions from all different sides of the "spectrum" and I must say that Nussbaum's "Liberty of Conscience" is easily the weakest and most surface-level analysis I have thus far read.
Her goal is to show that our religious tradition of nondiscrimination towards, and non-establishment of, religion(s) is based on a vision of human equality that finds embodiment in the Stoic philosophers and Roger Williams, founder of Rhode Island. I have never heard this point before and after hearing it, I can understand why. It is a tenuous view at best.
Most scholars argue, with evidence, that the libertarian-ish view towards religion stems from sources such as John Locke (who Nussbaum swears copied Williams's ideas), to a Montesqeiuian skepticism towards National government. Not so, says Nussbaum! Even though Williams was scarcely read in the New World and the Stoics were never quoted in the founders writings on religion, she finds ways to interpret the writings of Madison, Mason, Jefferson and the like through her desired lens.
Her next main concern is to argue for the rightness of the 'accomodationist' view towards religion. If a law or policy (you can be called to testify in court on Sundays) puts an undue burden on some religious folks, the state can accomodate (within reason). Nussbaum does succeed in showing that the Court HAS done this on many occasions, but does not show that they do it with any consistency (the cases that decide against accomodation are brushed off as "wrongly decided" withiout much explanation.
Also, Nussbaum fails to see that while she wants state neutrality towards religion AND accomodation of religion, she just cannot have both. The more you issue religious exemptions to the law, the less you are neutral towards religion. While she repeats many times her disagreement with Jusitice Scalia on this issue, she has certainly failed to convince me, as she does not put forward ANY CASE AT ALL that accomodations obliterate state neutrality towards religions. (She also fails to explain why she is very much against religious students being able to learn about Intelligent Design in science class and how this contrasts with her zeal for religious accomodations).
A side issue of Nussbaums is the question of whether the religion clauses were meant to apply to the states. Of course, this should be obvious, as the original draft of the first amendment, applying it to states, was swiftly struck down in the Senate. Nussbaum, as is usual, ignores the significance of this fact. The fact that she does not so much as MENTION Montesquieu's name ("Spirit of the Laws") is embarassing here, because the Federalist papers make very Montesquieuean arguments about why localities should be free to govern themselves (and agaisnt the Federal government trumping state governments on all things. And, unlike Roger Williams, we KNOW that Madison read and appreciated Montesquieu.
Normally I would not give such a long and drawn out review of a book, but I wanted to do so here so as to emphasize Nussbaum's embarassing and facile scholarship. She avoids hard arguments, gets tons of facts wrong, and reads things through her own very distorted lens (her "Roger Williams" interpretation is unjustified as it is pervasive).
If you are interested in religion/state issues, I am sure that you can find a better 363 pages than this.
3 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
Not impressed.
By drose
I had to purchase this book for a college religion course, and I have been gravely disappointed. Nussbaum draws comparisons that are unfounded; criticizes more than she analyzes; and uses irritatingly un-scholarly phrases and generalizations. If I wasn't enraged, I was incredibly bored. I hope that this next generation of religion scholars who are my cohorts will produce more substantive, respectful, and less predictable work.
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum PDF
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum EPub
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum Doc
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum iBooks
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum rtf
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum Mobipocket
Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America's Tradition of Religious Equality, by Martha Nussbaum Kindle
0 komentar:
Posting Komentar